Pampers Swaddlers vs Baby Dry: Which is the Best Diaper?

We are mom-supported. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Diaper changing is a daily routine task done by any parent with a newborn. While there are other brands, Pampers is one of the most outstanding brands that produces different types of diapers in various sizes to cater for babies in different age and stage.

Pampers Swaddlers vs Baby Dry are both popular varieties manufactured by Pampers. If you’ve been wondering which is the better variety between the two types, we will get into the details to help you make an earnest decision.

Pampers Swaddlers Vs Baby Dry: Which is Better?

If you’re in a hurry, we recommend Pampers Swaddlers because of the incredibly high level of absorbency than Baby Dry. Both versions are made with several layers of absorbency, but Pampers Swaddlers has been tested to hold more waste than the later.

It is an overnight diaper that holds the waste until the baby is changed without allowing the urine to sneak away. It is an excellent choice for baby blowouts, allowing both of you to have a comfortable overnight sleep.

Taking a look at customer reviews, you will be astonished by the amount of positive reviews the diaper has ridiculously garnered. Averagely, it has a customer rating of 4.8 while Pampers Baby Dry is averaged at 4.6. Parents love how the diapers are made to be soft without bringing rashes on the gentle bottom.

Pampers Swaddlers Review

Even though we’ve suggested Pampers Swaddlers as the winner, let see how the two versions compare by looking at their features.

Incredibly Soft

These versions have been created for babies with a weight limit of between 8 and 14 pounds. Since it is designed for newborns, the diaper is 2-times softer when compared to other popular brands in the same price range to be incredibly comfy on the sensitive bottom.

12-Hour Protection

This one is an overnight diaper created to be leak-proof for up to 12-hours. You little one can sleep all the night without the worry of diaper blow out.

What will further impress you are the channels that allow for the passage of air to the baby’s skin. With the constant air circulation, the baby will be dry and comfortable preventing the formation of diaper rashes.

Wetness Indicator

The favorite part amongst the parents is the wetness indicator that alerts you when the baby is wet and need to be changed. The indicator is usually imprinted as a line that changes from yellow to blue conveying when it’s time to change the baby.

Pampers Baby Dry Diaper Review

Comfort

Pampers Baby Dry diaper is soft like cotton for a comfy overnight sleep. The diaper is designed to stretch around the sides so it can fit comfortably without feeling tight.

Another notable feature are the air channels, that let the air pass right to the baby’s skin. The breathability feature helps keep the baby dry and comfy by preventing the build-up of moisture around the baby’s skin. 

12-Hour Leak Protection

What stands out about this diaper is the 3-absorbency layers that pulls the urine from getting to the baby’s skin. With the three absorbency channels, your baby can sleep the entire night, without the need of diaper change at night.

Also, they’re designed with comfy leg cuffs that blocks any leakage from sneaking through the baby’s legs.

Wetness Indicator

Pampers Baby Dry diapers constitutes a wetness indicator that change to a different color when the baby is in need of diaper change. The PH-sensitive material is usually located at the front where it can be spotted at a glance as you get on with the routine chores.

Similarities Between Pampers Swaddlers and Baby Dry

As you can see from our reviews, both diaper versions have been created to provide protection for up to 12-hours. With the long span, it means the baby can sleep the whole night without interfering with their night sleep to change the diapers. You can also travel for a 12-hour distance without the worry of blow outs.

Another important feature shared by the diapers are the absorbency channels that hold the wetness from sneaking out. Instead of accumulating on one side, the diapers are created to distribute the wetness across the channels to prevent blowouts that may result from massive build up.

If we look at the material, both of them have been created to be incredibly soft. They feel like cotton so the baby can be comfortable when it is worn.

Both of the diapers constitute a wetness indicator that change to a different color when it is time to change the diaper. And you can easily spot the line at a glance from the front.

They are both provided in a variety of sizes to suit the different shapes of babies. As the baby grows, you may have to transition from size one all through to size six or seven within the next couple of months.

When we compare the price, both Swaddlers and Baby Dry are priced the same. The price may however be higher if you want to compare the price with other brands.

Pampers Swaddlers or Pampers Baby Dry

The decision on which diaper to choose will be decided by the baby over time. If you have tried Pampers Swaddlers with constant negative results, then it advisable to try baby dry and vice versa. You can switch to a different version either by Pampers or another brand if you feel the two are not satisfactory. 

We suggest you purchase a small package to assess the comfort, leak-proof and the effects of the diapers on the baby’s skin. From there, you can make a decision on whether to buy a bigger package or shift to a different version.

Switch to a different diaper type or brand if:

  • The baby develops blisters or diaper rashes: diaper rashes may be as a result of waiting too long before you change the diapers. Change the diapers immediately or without waiting for long and see if the rashes will manifest. If there’s severe rashes even after immediate changing, it means the diapers is sensitive or allergic to the skin, probably because of the chemical composition in the diapers.
  • The baby is constantly itching or oozing
  • The diaper is not fully absorbent to contain blowouts
  • The baby feels uncomfortable and diapers does not fit to your expectations

Features to Consider When Shopping for Baby Diapers

Comfort

A good diaper should feel soft on the gentle skin of babies. The diaper must be stretchy on the sides so you can make adjustments to the baby’s shape. Most models are made with Velcro straps that lets you adjust the diaper for custom fit.

There are different diaper sizes, so make sure you check the sizing chart to make the right decision. This will depend on whether the baby is skinny or chubby and how the body changes over time.

Also, check to see if there are air passages to channel air right to the baby’s skin. This will help to keep the baby dry, reducing the build-up of moisture around the skin.

Absorbency Layers

The best diaper is comprised of several absorbency layers to accumulate and wick away the wetness from getting to the skin. This way, the baby is protected from rashes and reactions.

Overnight Protection

Choosing a diaper that survives up to 12-hours of wetness will let you sleep the whole night without having to wake up to change the baby. 

Another important feature are leg cliffs that prevents the wetness from leaking to the baby’s legs. There are other brands with a poop trap that contains the blowouts from spreading to the baby’s back.

Wetness Indicator 

The colored line is positioned on the front to signal to you when to remove the diaper. It turns to blue when the baby is wet and the diaper need to be replaced.

Sensitive Chemicals

Check the diapers to see if there are chemicals that may irritate the baby’s skin. Swap over to a different diaper type if there are severe allergic reactions around the legs.

Before you shop for diapers, we prefer you check reviews of users to see if there are allergy concerns reported by previous users. In most cases, chemically laden diapers will emit a heavy and terrible smell. If the baby is allergic to disposable diapers, you may need to switch to cloth diapers since they’re chemically free.

Important Diapering Tips

  • Don’t wait too long before you change the diaper to prevent irritation or diaper rash formation
  • Check the diaper size or baby weight chart when choosing a diaper for your newborn
  • You will need 7-8 pieces of diapers on average per day for the first days that may reduce to around 5-6 diapers within a couple of weeks

Bottom Line

Even though we suggest Pampers Swaddlers as the favorites, the battle between Pampers Swaddlers vs baby dry will be resolved by the baby.

Besides, both are reliable baby diapers by Pampers and you can swap over to a different diaper type if there are issues. With a try and error, it will only be a matter of time before you settle on the best diaper type to use in the diapering journey.

Scroll to Top