Enfamil Gentlease vs Similac Sensitive: The Difference

We are mom-supported. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Knowing the right formula for a sensitive or gassy baby can be quite a task. The reason for this is because of the hundreds of brands pointed to work satisfactorily to sensitive babies.

Gassy babies are quite fussy since they’re intolerant to proteins and lactose packaged in the formulas. Luckily, both Similac Sensitive and Enfamil Gentlease have proved to address the issue of lactose and proteins intolerance. 

But since it is pretty costly to purchase the two brands at once, right now, the heated debate is on the best choice with reference to Enfamil Gentlease vs Similac Sensitive. If you’re in the same dilemma, then read on.

Why Enfamil Gentlease or Similac Sensitive

Firstly, Similac Sensitive does not contain even a single trace of lactose for babies who are unable to digest the sugars. Instead, it is whey protein that’s completely hydrolyzed to be easily tolerated by the sensitive tummies.

Like Similac Sensitive, Enfamil Gentlease is a blend of digestible proteins that have virtually been reduced into tiny pieces so it’s gentle to the baby’s tummy.

In the end, the baby’s stomach will be less gassy since the central ingredients are super easy to break down by the lactose intolerant tummy.

Symptoms of Lactose and Protein Intolerance

If the infant is lactose intolerant, you will notice either one or more of the following signs a few hours after feeding on the formula milk:

  • Increased Gas
  • Colicky or excessive crying due to discomfort
  • Abdominal/ medical cramps and pain
  • Diarrhea or vomiting
  • Constipation

Your baby will feel like whistling or develop some unusual rash, red welts or some swells if they’re allergic to proteins immediately or a few hours after consuming the formula milk.

Similac Sensitive Infant Formula Review

The Similac brand has been the leading manufacturer in the infant formulas over the decades. It is the number one brand recommended by doctors in hospitals and a top infant formula choice by moms.

The infant formula is a balance nutrition created for fussy and gassy babies who are intolerant to lactose sensitivity.

It consists of OptiGro which is the amalgamation of lutein, vitamin E and DHA. These components are naturally obtainable in breastfed milk.

Lutein is vital for the healthy development of the macula part of the eye. It is also concentrated in parts of the brain that are responsible for learning and development.

DHA is a central ingredient in the development of the baby’s brain and the nervous system. Vitamin E on the other hand is the main component available in the baby’s brain; also playing a role in the overall growth of the eye and immune system.

It is non-GMO without the addition of lactose that gives the formula an edge over sensitive formulas in addressing the issue of gas, reflux, and spit up.

The formula is offered both in the powdered and ready-to-feed forms. But the ready-to-use bottles are pretty affordable than the powdered version even though the composition of ingredients is the same.

Enfamil Gentlease Review

Like Similac, Enfamil is a reputable brand backed by up to 100 years of nutritional pediatric research to make the formula as close to mom’s breast milk as possible.

It is a milk-based formula that’s exclusively created for babies with zero protein allergies. The formula constitutes easily digestible proteins that have partially been reduced for the gentleness of the baby’s tummy.

Enfamil Gentlease is available in Enfamil Premium Non-GMO, Enfamil Enspire Gentlease and Enfamil NeuroPro Gentlease. Perhaps the most noticeable difference is the absence of MFGM in Enfamil Premium Non-GMO.

MFGM includes prebiotics that supports the immune and the digestive system. On digestion, it influences the growth of bacteria that is helpful in digestion to eliminate the gassy issue.

What stands out about this brand is twice the amount of Omega 3 DHA than other established brands. But the favorite part is the Triple Health Guard (THG) blend comprising of up to 30 nutrients for healthy growth.

Better still, it is the only baby formula with inositol, an ingredient previously present in breastfed milk for brain development.

With these ingredients, Enfamil is very similar to mom’s breast milk reducing crying, fussiness and gas in just within 24-hours.  ,

Comparison Between Enfamil Gentlease and Similac Sensitive

Enfamil Gentlease and Similac Sensitive are both complete diets with similar nutritional provisions like mothers’ breast milk.

Similac consists of Lutein, Vitamin E, DHA and a combination of other special nutrients. In Enfamil, there is DHA and inositol. What’s best about Enfamil is twice the quantity of DHA than Similac. There’s also inositol and MFGM that are not provided by Similac.

The major difference is the absence of lactose in Similac Sensitive while Enfamil Gentlease does have reduced amount of lactose.

However, both brands are available in powdered and ready-to-use forms. You can switch to the ready to feed version if you feel like preparing the powdered form is quite a hustle.

Taste, Smell and Cost

Some users complain of a rancid smell emanating from the tin in the Similac brand. But the taste is somewhat better and very pleasant to many babies.

Enfamil Gentlease does not taste great as well. The taste may also be awful to some babies. It is somehow funky, bitter or metallic.

Similac Sensitive is pretty pricey than the Enfamil brand. However, we suggest you overlook the price and place your focus on the best formula that suits your little wonder.

Enfamil Gentlease and Similac Sensitive: Which is Better

The best way to determine the best formula for your baby is to understand the causes of intolerance. For babies who are fully intolerant to lactose, we suggest Similac Sensitive since it is formulated with zero sugars. This is because even a little of sugars would make the baby to be gassy and uncomfortable.

For infants intolerant to proteins, we recommend Enfamil Gentlease. The proteins therein have been broken into small pieces for simpler digestion.  

However, from our analysis on ingredients, Enfamil Gentlease does have an advantage of inositol and double DHA bringing it closer to breastfed milk. Overall, we find it to have more similar ingredients resembling the mom’s breast milk than Similac.

In the end, there’s no outright winner since the two products have been created to provide relief to gassy, fussy and crying babies. The deciding factor will be the baby depending on how they respond to the formula.

Common Lactose Intolerance Tests

The severity of lactose intolerance will vary from baby to baby. If you’re curious, or the baby is experiencing some complications, you should visit the baby’s doctor to rule out if it is lactose intolerance or something else is wrong. The doctor may perform either of the following tests:

  • Lactose intolerance blood test
  • Bowel acidity test
  • Intestinal diagnosis
  • Hydrogen breath test

If the issue is lactose intolerance and not a medical problem, the doctor may recommend reduced or lactose-free formula or; other formula options he may deem fit.  

Wrap Up

Some infants will do well with Similac Sensitive while others will be fine with Enfamil Gentlease. For that reason, the battle between Enfamil Gentlease vs Similac Sensitive will only be settled by the baby or through pediatrician’s advice.

For new parents, lactose and proteins intolerance are widespread problems affecting a lot of babies at the tender age. Any of these products will help address the gassy and colic problems unless there are unusual symptoms that may need expertly advice from a doctor.    

Scroll to Top